Analyst explains why Target may remain uncompetitive

Wednesday at 7:50pm AST · November 18, 2026 2 min read
Last updated on November 18, 2026 at 7:50pm AST

Target’s (Target Corporation Stock Quote, Chart, News, Analysts, Financials NYSE:TGT) stronger-than-expected third-quarter results and improved earnings outlook have failed to convince Roth Capital Partners analyst Bill Kirk that the retailer is making the best use of tariff refunds, which he believes should be reinvested to improve its competitive position.

Kirk maintained his “Neutral” rating and US$142 .00 target on the Minneapolis-based retailer, warning that competitors could gain an advantage by directing more of their tariff refunds toward pricing and other investments.

“Target reported a 3Q comparable sales and earnings beat (+5.6% y/y vs cons. +3.8% and $2.65 vs. cons. $2.08, respectively),” Kirk said in his Nov. 18 report.

Target reported third-quarter net sales of US$27.1-billion, exceeding consensus expectations of US$26.5-billion. Comparable sales increased 5.6%, compared with 3.8% in the previous quarter. Adjusted earnings per share reached US$2.65, ahead of consensus of US$2.08, although approximately US$0.50 of the result came from tariff refunds. Excluding that benefit, Kirk estimated underlying earnings of approximately US$2.15 per share. The company’s adjusted operating margin reached 6.2%, above consensus of 4.9%, with tariff refunds contributing approximately 1.1 percentage points. Digital sales increased 9.8% year-over-year, compared with 8.7% in the previous quarter, although Kirk said growth continued to trail leading competitors.

Target raised its fiscal 2026 sales growth guidance to approximately 6% from 5% and increased its adjusted earnings-per-share forecast to between US$10.65 and US$11.40 from US$9.90 to US$10.90. The revised earnings outlook includes approximately US$2.15 per share in tariff refund benefits received during the second and third quarters.

Kirk thinks the improved financial performance is encouraging but questioned whether retaining the refunds as earnings is the right longer-term strategy.

“3Q was a strong quarter, but we continue to believe tariff refunds should be reinvested rather than fall to the bottom line,” he said. “With competitors re-investing a larger proportion of refunds, Target may become less competitive.”

He said investors should watch early holiday shopping trends and whether management plans to increase spending on pricing and customer acquisition.

Kirk’s unchanged US$142 target is based on a discounted cash flow valuation, equivalent to approximately 7.7 times expected EBITDA over the next 12 months and 13.3 times forward earnings.

 

-30-

Author photo

Rod Weatherbie

Writer

Rod Weatherbie is a journalist based in Prince Edward Island. Since 2004, he has written extensively about the Canadian property and casualty insurance landscape. He was also a founder and contributing editor for a Toronto-based arts website and a PEI-based food magazine. His fiction and poetry have been featured in The Fiddlehead, The Antigonish Review, and Juniper.

displaying rededs