Trending >

Does BlackBerry have security issues or national security issues?

Northern Securities analyst Sameet Kanade says that while RIM, to date, has denied its data could be intercepted or decrypted, this week’s announcement by the Indian government casts serious doubt on that assertion.

In a letter to service providers, the Indian Government this week asked that telecoms offering BlackBerry service implement RIM’s interception solution by December 31st.

In that letter, the government said “Blackberry interception solution is in the final stages of development and testing by RIM and the telecom service providers in conjunction with an Legal Intercepting (LI) vendor. The developed solution should be deployed in coordination with RIM and offered for testing to the respective TERM cells on or before 31-12-12.”

Earlier this year, after some resistance, RIM agreed to provide Indian security agencies with a solution for lawful interception of encrypted data and monitoring, including the technology to read decrypted emails.

India is an important emerging market for RIM. A recent study by Indian-based Cyber Media says mobile phone sales in India crossed the 100 million mark in the first six months of 2012. The report said BlackBerry had a 12.1% share of this market.

Northern Securities analyst Sameet Kanade says that while RIM, to date, has denied its data could be intercepted or decrypted, this week’s announcement by the Indian government casts serious doubt on that assertion. He believes this may create headwinds for the company, as one of the key value propositions for enterprise and government users might no longer be valid. Kanade points to a recent shift within the US government, where several agencies have switched to Android or iOS platforms. In a research update to clients this morning, Kanade reiterated his SELL rating and $4.50 target on Research in Motion.



Are you a private company looking to learn more about TSX and TSXV?
Discover How Canadian Entrepreneurs are Utilizing TSX and TSXV as Platforms for Growth

Event Details: Thursday, November 8, 2012 – Morris J Wosk Centre for Dialogue, 580 Hastings Street

• Canadian and international market update
• Best practices for going public
• Finance panel discussion with leading Canadian investment banks

Who Should Attend? This event is for CEOs, CFOs, and COOs

Email Maureen Butcher for availability as space is limited: maureen.butcher (at)


RIM’s secure network has been a constant source of debate in the tech community, and to those with an eye towards privacy legislation. After being pressed on security issues in India, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates last year by BBC reporter Rory Cellan-Jones, then co-CEO Mike Lazaridis walked out of the interview, but not before declaring: “We don’t have a security problem…this is a national security issue.”

Then, a year ago, RIM’s Blackberry blog was hacked by protestors unhappy with the company’s cooperation with Scotland Yard who were concerned that crimes had been organized by rioters using BlackBerry Messenger.

RIM”s approach to security is fundamentally different than other device makers. The company uses complex codes to encrypt data as it travels between a BlackBerry server and the BlackBerry device. All BlackBerry traffic runs through the company’s own secure Network Operations Centers.

Tech writer Carmi Levy, writing about these issues for IT Business last year said “RIM’s best-of-breed mobile security model is so good that it gets singled out while other vendors – I’m looking at you, Apple – get a free ride (okay, who are we kidding? Traffic on iPhones and other smartphone platforms is so relatively easy to pick off that it’s safe to assume that governments are already monitoring them.)”

Security expert Dan Croft of Mission Critical Wireless told Ars Technica last week that “It’s premature to run the obituaries on RIM. Clearly they are facing some significant issues, but there are still millions and millions of BlackBerrys out there that are operating just fine. That being said, what we’re typically seeing is not RIM getting ripped out of an enterprise environment. We’re just seeing the addition of non-BlackBerry devices.”

While Croft says recent outages of RIM’s network are troubling, the company still has a significant moat in the enterprise world.

“If it were up to IT managers there would still be only one solution out there and it would be called BlackBerry,” he said.



We Hate Paywalls Too!

At Cantech Letter we prize independent journalism like you do. And we don't care for paywalls and popups and all that noise That's why we need your support. If you value getting your daily information from the experts, won't you help us? No donation is too small.

Make a one-time or recurring donation

About The Author /

Cantech Letter founder and editor Nick Waddell has lived in five Canadian provinces and is proud of his country's often overlooked contributions to the world of science and technology. Waddell takes a regular shift on the Canadian media circuit, making appearances on CTV, CBC and BNN, and contributing to publications such as Canadian Business and Business Insider.
insta twitter facebook


One thought on “Does BlackBerry have security issues or national security issues?

  1. Why would anyone listen to Kanade? He’s doing such a good job that his own company is rushing headlong into the toilet! Have you ever wondered about the correlation between an analysts negativity and the position that their firm holds?

Leave a Reply