Quebecor’s (Quebecor Stock Quote, Chart, News, Analysts, Financials TSX:QBR.B) proposed $31-billion acquisition of Telus could transform the company into a major national telecommunications provider, but regulatory opposition and uncertainty over whether Telus will accept the offer present significant obstacles, according to Desjardins Securities analyst Jerome Dubreuil.
In a Nov. 17 reseaerch update, Dubreuil lowered his target for Quebecor to $76.00 from $82.00 while maintaining his “Buy” rating. He also raised his Telus target to $14.50 from $13, maintaining a “Hold” recommendation.
Dubreuil said he was surprised by the proposal but sees “a compelling long-term strategic rationale for the Québec-based cableco, with the transaction potentially transforming the industry’s small disruptor into a scaled national telecom player.”
The offer represents a 44% premium to Telus’s closing share price on Nov. 16 and values the company at approximately eight times Dubreuil’s estimated fiscal 2027 Adjusted EBITDA.
“While the large premium (44 per cent on Monday’s close) and valuation (8.0 times our FY27 adjusted EBITDA estimate) are attractive, T’s board has to weigh that against (1) significant regulatory risk, and (2) the prospect of selling to a highly valued QBR while its own shares were depressed,” he said.
Dubreuil identified regulatory approval as the biggest obstacle, given Ottawa’s longstanding efforts to establish a fourth national wireless competitor. “Allowing QBR to acquire T would seemingly run counter to that objective by reducing the national wireless market from four players back to three,” he said.
However, he said consolidation toward three major wireless operators is becoming more common internationally, reflecting the economics of operating mature telecommunications networks. “Three-player wireless markets are common internationally and would seemingly be consistent with Canada’s relatively modest population and large country size,” Dubreuil said.
The analyst cited recent consolidation in the United Kingdom, potential changes in France and the difficulties faced by DISH as a fourth wireless competitor in the United States.
Telus’s board also presents a significant hurdle, particularly given uncertainty surrounding the regulatory process and the value of Quebecor shares being offered in a potential transaction.
“We like the destination for QBR, but the road there looks challenging, with T likely demanding meaningful deal-certainty protections and a pro forma entity being more difficult to value,” Dubreuil said. “We note that T has not accepted the offer; QBR has simply made its proposal public.”
Dubreuil assigned a 25% probability to a transaction being completed and incorporated that assumption into his revised targets.
Under a no-deal scenario, he expects Quebecor’s valuation premium over Canada’s three largest telecommunications operators to narrow, reflecting increased acquisition risk and potential changes in how regulators view the company. If the transaction proceeds, he believes the combined company could command a valuation premium over BCE and Rogers Communications, supported by lower capital spending requirements and stronger earnings growth.
“We used a probability-weighted approach to support our revised target prices,” Dubreuil said.
He also cautioned that Quebecor could be required to improve its offer or provide substantial financial protections if regulators block the acquisition.
“Applying these probability-weighted outcomes, we lowered our target price to $76 (from $82) and reiterate our Buy rating on QBR, although it remains our lowest-ranked Buy, behind BCE and RCI,” he said.
Dubreuil’s revised $14.50 Telus target similarly reflects his estimated 25% probability of a completed transaction.
-30-
Roth Capital Partners analyst Max Masucci downgraded Rapid Micro Biosystems (Rapid Micro Biosystems I Stock Quote, Chart, News, Analysts, Financials… [Read More]
National Bank Financial analyst Baltej Sidhu lowered his target for Ballard Power Systems (Ballard Power Systems Stock Quote, Chart, News,… [Read More]
Oddity Technology’s (Oddity Tech Stock Quote, Chart, News, Analysts, Financials NASDAQ:ODD) sharp decline from earlier highs could present an opportunity… [Read More]
NowVertical Group’s (NowVertical Group Stock Quote, Chart, News, Analysts, Financials TSXV:NOW) growing artificial intelligence business and recent $15.1-million financing could… [Read More]
National Bank Financial analyst Nathan Po raised his target for Mattr Corp. (Mattr Corp. Stock Quote, Chart, News, Analysts, Financials… [Read More]
On Nov. 16, RBC Capital Markets analyst Sabahat Khan raised his target for AutoCanada (AutoCanada Stock Quote, Chart, News, Analysts,… [Read More]