Trending >

Opinion: keeping unvaccinated kids out of school is the right move

unvaccinated kids

Officials with Ottawa Public Health are doing the right thing in keeping unvaccinated kids out of school until their vaccinations are up to date. Yet, the situation also brings up the problem of what to do with those children whose parents refuse to have them immunized. How far can and should we go as a society to force these families to do the right thing?

First, the cases in Ottawa. A City of Ottawa press release recently confirmed three related measles cases in Ottawa and Lanark County, involving at least one adult and one child, and Ottawa Public Health has since contacted 500 individuals who may have been exposed to the three infected patients, possibly at one of a select list of locales around town, including the Children’s Hospital of Eastern Ontario, a shopping mall on Carling Avenue and a restaurant in Kanata. (The City has posted online the list of places of possible exposure, including dates and times.)

“We’ve identified where the cases who’ve had measles went, and that certainly is where people may be at risk,” says Dr. Carolyn Pim, associate medical officer of health with OPH, told the CBC. “[But] if people are fully immunized, their risk is extremely low. The measles vaccine is very effective.”

Hence the problem in the case of children who for any of a number of reasons have not been vaccinated against measles or who have been incompletely vaccinated. In Ottawa, officials are saying that this group may be required to stay home from school for up to three weeks if it’s thought that they might have been exposed to the virus.

This is a good move.

The unvaccinated child stands a much greater risk of contracting measles, known to be the most contagious of the so-called childhood illnesses. And if infected, he or she becomes yet another pathway for the virus to spread throughout society. Thus, to prevent more of the population from getting sick (sometimes very sick – one in five children with the measles is admitted to hospital for the disease and one in 1,000 will die from it), it’s crucial that we keep as many of those in the un- and under-vaccinated group away from other young children, even during periods of minor outbreak such as the one in Ottawa. But do we need to do more?

Every year, Ontario school boards suspend thousands of students for having incomplete vaccination records. These efforts are meant to bring up vaccination rates which currently hover around 90 per cent across the country – healthy numbers, to be sure, but still not enough to create herd immunity and minimize the potential spread a disease to a larger population (95 per cent immunization is thought to be the magic number).

And every year, the majority of those issued suspensions actually do get immunized, since most of the time the problem is one of unintentional neglect on the parents’ part to bring their child in to get immunized.

But that still leaves a smaller percentage of children who for either medical reasons or reasons of belief are not being immunized. The Immunization of School Pupils Act allows parents to receive exemptions on medical grounds when there are contraindications against vaccination but also on religious or conscience-based grounds. And it’s this latter exemption that is likely to set off alarm bells for parents and has the potential to become a real problem if, that is, the unvaccinated-due-to-belief cohort were found to be the main vehicle in North American society for the further spread of diseases like the measles.

And, unfortunately, it has.

A study this year in the Journal of the American Medical Association shows that more than half of cases of measles in the U.S. in recent years occurred in individuals with no history of measles vaccination. And a full 71 per cent of those without vaccination had non-medical (in other words, belief-based) reasons for their non-participation.

Fairly directly, then, these numbers point to the belief-based objectors as the prime cause of measles outbreaks, a result which the study’s authors say should have “broad implications for vaccine practice and policy.”

How far can we go to push parents to immunize their children? That depends on how you weigh the pros and cons of allowing group immunization to stay well below the sought-after 95 per cent. And it depends on whether you feel you’re got enough proof that the risks of harm to both the unvaccinated child and to society at large are in fact real.

The question is, how much more proof do you need?

More Cantech Science

We Hate Paywalls Too!

At Cantech Letter we prize independent journalism like you do. And we don't care for paywalls and popups and all that noise That's why we need your support. If you value getting your daily information from the experts, won't you help us? No donation is too small.

Make a one-time or recurring donation

About The Author /

Jayson is a writer, researcher and educator with a PhD in political philosophy from the University of Ottawa. His interests range from bioethics and innovations in the health sciences to governance, social justice and the history of ideas.
insta twitter facebook


  1. this is absolute bullcrap. its actually the vaccinated kids that are shedding the disease mostly. which said disease isnt even that bad as long as you are of decent health and even better if you have the right herbs that support the immune system.

  2. This is BS. How long does immunity from the measles vaccine last? The CDC says 12-15
    This leaves millions with no immunity and for decades! Where is the so called herd immunity? The numbers keep changing from 68% to 95! One of the best immunologists from Harvard, Dr Pollen, says there is no herd immunity as well as many other scientists.
    The risks of vaccines and the fact that no one is accountable is never mentioned.
    Read VAERS (US reporting system).
    Read reports from the US Vaccine Injury Court. Thousands of injuries and deaths and very under reported. CDC says the figures represents about 10%.
    The US is the most vaccinated developed country with the highest infant mortality rate and very high for children under 5.
    Canada one of the only developed countries with NO compensation Program.

  3. it is simple, if your kids are immunized why are you worrying that mine aren’t? Exactly what are we trying to accomplish?

  4. “isnt even that bad as long as you are of decent health” …. so if you yourself had a compromised immune systerm, you would be ok with everyone not be vaccinated?

  5. completely. you know what one of the things that harms the immune system are? vaccines. they arent very upfront about everything in them. its done intentionally. also herd immunity does not come from people vaccinated.

Leave a Reply